Birthright citizenship fight shows US identity debate is far from settled

Birthright citizenship has long been considered a settled issue in the United States. It became the law of the land in 1868 with the 14th…

Birthright citizenship has long been considered a settled issue in the United States. It became the law of the land in 1868 with the 14th Amendment to the Constitution that guaranteed citizenship, due process and equal protection to anyone born in the US.

Originally designed to ensure citizenship for slaves brought from Africa, its application was extended to Chinese and other groups in the aftermath of the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. It was further solidified by the case that Wong Kim Ark brought to the Supreme Court in 1898. Born in San Francisco to parents from China, he was stopped from re-entering the US and appealed to the Supreme Court, which ruled in his favour, thereby reinforcing birthright citizenship.

Why is this issue again at the centre of deliberations in the US Supreme Court in 2026? In part, this is driven by today’s heated debates over immigration and voting rights, but something deeper is involved as well: American cultural DNA and mental habits.

What is cultural DNA? In a nutshell, it’s the story we tell ourselves about what it means to be a member of a culture or nation. Cultural DNA tends to be long-lasting, resistant to change and unconsciously assumed by members of the culture rather than overtly discussed until it pops up in heated public debate, as we are seeing right now in the US.

In the case of birthright citizenship, two narratives are particularly important. One is a story of radical democracy that takes its cue from the assertion in the Declaration of Independence that “all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights”.

Widespread anti-immigrant operations spark fear in Asian communities across the US

After the American civil war, the radical democracy narrative was used primarily in the struggle against racism, but over time it expanded its purview to include gender, class and other issues.

Don't Miss:

Birthright citizenship fight shows US identity debate is far from settled

US to screen for Ebola at airports, one American in DR Congo infected

Milei guts China currency lifeline after Trump ultimatum on financial ties: reports

How China is becoming the gravitational centre of global diplomacy

Cuba warns of ‘bloodbath’ if US attacks; Washington adds sanctions

3 killed in shooting at a San Diego mosque and 2 suspects are dead, police say