Here We Remain: A World That Abides Slaughter

Atop all the others inflicted on us came last week’s sickening spectacle of two vengeful, lying, broken old men – one a longtime killer of children, one a petty useful idiot abetting him – alternately celebrating and threatening genocide before “we the peoples of the United Nations.” Born of :”the defiance of hope” to enable us to “live together in peace,” the forum now hosts the perpetrators of unspeakable atrocities. Omar El Akkad: “One day everyone will have always been against this.”

Even before war criminals spoke at the U.N., everyone was already against everything Trump’s done, from his insane, drone-packed arch to the other $1.8 billion vanity projects to his latest tantrum over bad press. Despite multiple court rulings against it, the ensuing press ban is still partly, messily in place, with CNN, MS NOW and Politico facing dubious access, other major media finally finding their spine and solidarity, and the havoc offering us the droll sight of a needy guy who never met a camera he didn’t like in one farcical silent movie, a “shrinking figure gesticulating wildly into the wind.” The attention whore has tried to compensate with wildly weird and illegal PR stunts: Claiming an entire hemisphere, boasting, “Only Trump” and an ad pleading “Love Me” on the taxpayer dime in “an astonishing misuse of public resources more fitting for North Korea.”

The final own goal of his attack on the press, teased by a frantic promo, was the launch of Trump TV: The Essentials Station, the White House YouTube channel recast as a 24/7 livestream of Trump’s “greatest hits.” Cue aJuly speech at Mt. Rushmore about “the communist menace,” last year’s speech at dinner with King Charles, a 2016 speech in Kentucky recalling the wet stairs he overcame. YouTube’s real-time data let the “king of ratings” see it quickly crash and burn, from a paltry 8,000 viewers to half that to 1,000 to 704 as J.D. announced stripping health care from 760,000 people, way below the 2,000-plus watching birds snack on seeds and nuts. Many relished the flop – “Fascism is awesome!” – or suggested new slots: “Wake Up & Rage Tweet, Ketchup-Throwing, They’re Eating our Pets, The Great MAGA Crypto Scam, Wheel of Pardons” and, from 2:01 to 2:02 a.m., “Covfefe.”

Then came a clumsy, swooning welcome – “the deference was deafening” – for his strongman soulmate Chinese President Xi Jinping, the world’s biggest jailer of journalists and never mind the “communist menace,” with its empty pomp, cartoonish tour of a hole-in-the-ground ballroom and million-year helipad – “He has a great interest in granite” – and zero substance. The next day, with his approval rating “somewhere between Ebola and Ed Sheeran,” he waddled into the 81st session of the UN General Assembly and threatened one of its130 participants with war crimes, musing, “Do I annihilate the Islamic Republic quickly and drive them into hell?” Iran’s delegation swiftly walked out. Mehdi Hasan: “For shame. The president of the United States goes to the United Nations and threatens genocide against a member state in front of the world. This is where we’re at.”

Slurring, stumbling, wandering at unhinged, racist length – details here – Trump boasted about murdering over 200 people “at war with civilization” in illegal boat strikes, claimed trans people are a national security risk, celebrated (and inflated) the theft of Venezuela’s oil, charged trans people are a national security risk, inanely declaimed “to the (raping and plundering) victor belong the spoils” – become, terrifyingly, “a demagogue who hijacked American democracy…devolving into a mad king before our eyes.” The speech, a “sad and dangerous national embarrassment” with its “ridiculous braggadocio, narcissistic puffery, absurd demonstrable lies, open criminality and deranged, murderous threats” landed “with silence inside the hall and a pile of fact checks outside it, (the) death rattle of a rapist president and what’s left of America’s reputation on the world stage.”

Then world leaders “went back to making plans that don’t include the United States.” Or, in the case of Denmark, trolling. Trump has created a fictional backstory for a “deal” on Greenland “long in the making – you could go back many, many decades, probably centuries” – that just repackages an existing 1951 deal; ahead of meeting held later at the U.N., officials played the Sondheim song Send In The Clowns. At this point, writes Paul Krugman, it’s “Underwear on the Outside” time, a callback to Woody Allen’s 1971 film Bananas about a third-world nation’s absurd strongman. Coverage of the U.N. focused on Trump’s rabid rejection of global cooperation or the fact almost everything he said was a lie. The bigger story: “The leader of what used to be the world’s most powerful nation, now collapsing before our eyes, has clearly, undeniably lost his mind.”

Other speakers tried to steer the conversation back to reality. Secretary-General António Guterres stressed the primacy of international law, especially in Palestine, calling the birth of the U.N. “an act of defiance (by) people who refuse to surrender the future to fear…who know our futures are bound together.” But with accountability: The U.N. deems Gaza “a collective crime,” a “live-streamed atrocity…sustained by the complicity of influential third states”; their complicity must be confronted for the rule of law to survive. Holding photos of Iranian children killed in U. S. strikes, Iran’s president Masoud Pezeshkian argued it is Trump who has defied international law, while Iran has remained committed to negotiations. “We have only defended ourselves. We are not terrorists.” He also called for accountability on all sides, asking “why Israel kills, yet Iran is subject to sanction.”

Israel kills. And Benjamin Netanyahu offered a bellicose “potpourri of lies and incitement.” In his “furious, ugly and disgraceful” diatribe, he called universal charges of genocide “the biggest lie of the century,” summoning the chutzpah to call the carnage in Gaza “the opposite of genocide.” Anyone who disagreed, he raved, was “a moral coward” – About half the Assembly, who walked out as Zionist allies chanted “Am Yisrael Chai,” “the Nation of Israel lives”; Hundreds of protesters outside, with about 100 arrested; including Brooklyn Council Member Chi Ossé, who later posted a selfie in handcuffs with “Free Palestine. Netanyahu burn in hell”; and world leaders “spreading lies about my country and our brave soldiers,” “tyrants (in) a global anti-Jewish conspiracy (to) erase us from the face of the Earth. Instead of collapsing, we delivered devastating blows to all of them with our great American friends.”

There was much more. He brandished a pager in tribute to Israel’s 2024 operation targeting Hezbollah in Lebanon that killed 12 and wounded over 3,000. He dismissed settler violence against Palestinians in the occupied West Bank as the work of “juvenile delinquents.” He said bombing Iran was “’one of the easiest decisions I’ve ever had to make.” Shameless, he claimed Israel still has “the most moral army in the world.” He denied a Haaretz report, confirmed by the New York Times, that Egypt’s intel chief warned him in September 2023 Hamas was planning “a major attack,” but he declined to pass the tip on to his intelligence agencies. He called the duly elected mayor of his host city, who deems him a war criminal and wants the ICC’s arrest warrant issued, anti-Semitic,” claiming “many Jews no longer feel safe in New York.” He evidently doesn’t; he flew into New Jersey.

He ended his speech with a Bible verse from Samuel that describes the genocide of the Amalek, enemies of Israel, after God orders King Saul, “‘Go and completely destroy those wicked people.” Saul mostly does, but spares their king and “the best of the sheep and cattle. Then the prophet Samuel admonishes him: “(God) sent you on a mission, but you have rejected the word of the Lord, and the Lord has rejected you as king over Israel.” Samuel’s murderous gist: “Nezah Israel lo yeshaker,” or “the eternity of Israel will not falter.” Bibi’s lesson: “We have no choice but genocide.” And so they made it: Over 73,900 direct deaths, about half women and children. Over 175,000 wounded, often gravely. Roughly 641,000 ultimately dead, from destruction of the healthcare system, malnutrition, disease. The bodies of perhaps 10,000 more still remain under the rubble.

And the devastation goes on. Under Israel’s blockade, there is widespread hunger, 90% of Gazans remain homeless, trauma and illness go untreated. More than 900 wheelchairs donated by two Australian non-profits for over 11,000 disabled children – Gaza has the most child amputees per capita in the world – are held hostage in Jordan warehouses by preposterous Israeli restrictions on anything that could “serve a military purpose.” Other victims of insane “dual-use” rules: Portable toilets, sleeping bags, tarps. bandages, diapers, shampoo, tent poles. And presumably kites, after Bibi announced “targeted strikes”against the launch of any kites, balloons or drones, with the IDF ordered to “act forcefully” against perps. What else to expect from a place where a government official calls Palestinian children “explosives of the future.” “What a childhood in Gaza teaches: Want less.”

The cruelty, madness, loss continue to spark palpable rage. Actor Mandy Patinkin, a Jew aware of history, on the corrosive effect of “the revenge business“: “How could it be done to you and your ancestors, and you turn around and do it to someone else?!” Omar El Akkad – born in Egypt, raised in Qatar and Canada, a US citizen – on “what it means to live under an ordering of the world that abides slaughter, and whether any ordering ever stood for anything at all.” He wrote the book One Day Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This, though its full title is One day, when it’s safe, when there’s no personal downside to calling a thing what it is, when it’s too late to hold anyone accountable, everyone will always have been against this,” what one critic calls “a cathartic savaging” of empire, Western hypocrisy on Gaza, selective empathy in “the most privileged sliver of global society.”

“When the unspeakable happens, the world should stop but it doesn’t,” he writes of the comfortable bubble of a white nationalist world run by broken men and their accomplices that blithely “shrugs at one kind of slaughter,” having developed “a terrible immunity…When it mattered, who sided with justice and who sided with power?” The time to choose is now, he adds, and hindsight will not undo or excuse their crimes: “At the time they say, ‘Yes, this is tragic, but necessary’…The alternative to the countless killed and maimed and orphaned… screaming from under the rubble (is) barbarism.” ” There is no way to finish the sentence, ‘It is unfortunate that tens of thousands of children are dead but…'” he movingly writes. “There is no such thing as someone else’s children.”

The evening after Netanyahu assailed Zohran Mamdani as anti-Semitic – he dismissed the speech as “baseless lies meant to sanitize his genocide against Palestinians” – the good mayor was home at Gracie Mansion. He was hosting Palestinian families from Gaza who have lost family members there or have made their way to America as refugees to “honor their contributions to the city and acknowledge the losses they have endured.” They ate a meal; a smiling Mamdani glided around the table, filling water glasses. And they planted an olive tree – for Palestinians, source of food, wood, fuel, symbol of peace, hope, resilience, a deep connection to their heritage and ancestral land. Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish: ‘”Here we remain, as long as thyme and olives remain.” Zohran Mamdani: “May peace be our future.”

A young boy in Gaza mourns his murdered mother Getty Image